Skip to content
The JournalGuides

Should You Make a Claim or Pay Out of Pocket? How a Claim Affects Your Premium

November 18, 202611 min read
Should You Make a Claim or Pay Out of Pocket? How a Claim Affects Your Premium

Paying for a small loss yourself can cost less than the premium increase a claim triggers, but only when the damage is genuinely small and nobody is hurt. Here is how fault, Ontario's minor at-fault accident rule, accident forgiveness, and home claims actually move your premium.

In Ontario, a claim raises your premium mainly when you are found at fault, and the increase usually lands at renewal rather than the week you call. Paying out of pocket tends to win when the damage is small, you are at fault, nobody was hurt, and your record is worth protecting. It rarely wins when someone was injured, another person's vehicle or property was damaged, or the loss is larger than your deductible and the next few years of premium combined.

The decision is arithmetic wrapped in a set of rules. The rules are the part most drivers never see, and they are what makes one small collision worth claiming and another worth paying quietly.

In short

  • Fault decides most of it. Under Ontario's Fault Determination Rules you can be found anywhere from zero to 100 percent at fault, and if you are 50 percent or more at fault there is a good chance your premium rises at renewal.
  • One qualifying minor at-fault accident is protected. Since June 1, 2016 an insurer cannot use a minor at-fault accident to raise your premium if nobody was injured, no insurer paid anything, and the damage was under $2,000 per vehicle or property and you paid it yourself. The protection applies once every three years.
  • Not-at-fault claims generally do not raise your rate, but the claim still shows on your insurance record.
  • Accident forgiveness (OPCF 39) only works if it was already on the policy, it covers one at-fault accident, and it does not travel to a new insurer.
  • Home claims work the same way: the real cost is the claims-free discount you lose plus any surcharge, not the payout itself.

Shop 17+ insurers in one go.

Get a free quote and a dedicated Ontario broker who explains every option and stays with you to renewal.

Start your quote

The whole decision in one calculation

A claim is a trade. Your insurer pays a loss and then prices the next few years around it. Compare both sides:

Your side of the ledger: the deductible you pay, the claims-free discount you lose, and the higher premium for as long as the incident stays on your record. Ontario applications ask for accidents and claims from the past six years, and most provinces treat an at-fault accident as relevant for up to six years.

Their side of the ledger: what the insurer would actually pay you, which is the repair or replacement cost minus your deductible, and only up to the coverage and limits you bought.

Run it as an illustration with your own numbers. Say your premium is $2,400 a year, an at-fault collision adds 25 percent ($600), and it is rated for three renewal years. The premium cost is $1,800. Add a $500 deductible and the claim has to be worth roughly $2,300 before it breaks even. A $3,000 repair clears that easily. A $900 parking-lot dent does not come close, and paying it yourself is the cheaper choice even though it stings that week.

Two things shift that math hard: Ontario's minor at-fault accident rule, which can take the premium increase off the table entirely, and accident forgiveness, which does the same thing by contract.

How fault is decided, and why the percentage matters

After a collision your insurer assigns fault using the Fault Determination Rules, Ontario Regulation 668/93. The rules run to diagrams covering more than 40 accident situations and apply regardless of road or weather conditions, visibility, or point of impact, and fault can be shared between drivers. Being charged or not charged by police does not decide it either.

  • 0 percent at fault: the claim is not chargeable, and the incident should not raise your rate. It still appears on your record.
  • Partially at fault: shared fault is common, and each driver's own insurer pays according to the percentage.
  • 50 percent or more at fault: FSRA says there is a good chance your premium rises at renewal, and the at-fault accident goes on your insurance record.
  • Someone else driving your car: if you lend your vehicle and that driver is found 50 percent or more at fault, the accident goes on your record, not only theirs.

Insurers draw their own chargeable line inside those rules. Intact, for example, treats an accident where you are 26 percent or more at fault as at-fault and chargeable. That is why two drivers with the same collision can see very different renewals.

Timing matters too: the premium typically changes at renewal, not the day the claim is reported. If your policy renews in two weeks, the increase can arrive quickly.

The Ontario rule that protects one minor at-fault accident

This is the rule most drivers have never heard of, and it is the reason a small at-fault collision is often best paid out of pocket.

FSRA's consumer guide to auto insurance sets out the protection. An insurer can no longer use a minor at-fault accident that occurs on or after June 1, 2016 to increase your premium when all of the following are true:

  • no payment has been made by any insurer,
  • there are no injuries,
  • damage to each car and to property was less than $2,000 per vehicle, and
  • the at-fault driver paid for the damage.

The protection is limited to one minor accident every three years. Meet every condition and the increase is off the table, which is exactly why paying a small repair yourself can be the rational move rather than the generous one.

Two cautions. Meeting the rule does not erase the incident from claims history reporting, and a new insurer may still see it and factor it in when you switch. And the protection says nothing about the police: reporting an accident to police and filing a claim with an insurer are separate obligations.

Two thresholds that get confused: $2,000 and $5,000

Both numbers come up in the same conversation, and they mean different things.

  • $2,000 per vehicle or property is the insurance threshold in the minor at-fault accident rule above.
  • $5,000 in combined damage, or any injury, or damage to private, municipal or highway property, is when Ontario's Highway Traffic Act requires the collision to be reported to police. The reportable threshold rose from $2,000 to $5,000 on January 1, 2025, and police services publish it in their collision reporting guidance.

So a collision can be reportable to police and still qualify as a minor accident for insurance, or the reverse. Paying out of pocket does not remove a legal duty to report the collision.

Reporting an accident is not the same as filing a claim

This distinction is the practical heart of the whole question.

FSRA's guidance is to report the accident to your broker, agent or insurer within seven days, or as quickly as possible afterward, and warns that failing to report within a reasonable time may mean the insurer does not honour the claim. Reporting gives them the facts. Filing a claim asks them for money.

Those are separate steps. You can notify your insurer that a collision happened, keep the file open, and decide later whether to ask for payment, which is what a broker usually recommends when the damage is borderline. And there is a good reason not to stay silent: injuries are not always obvious on the day, and an injured person in Ontario generally has two years to bring a claim. A report creates a record you can rely on if something surfaces later.

Silence has its own cost. Intact notes that an accident that was not reported to police, such as a hit-and-run, can end up treated as an at-fault claim under your collision coverage. And under Ontario's Insurance Act, a knowingly false statement on an application or a renewal can invalidate a claim, so hiding an incident is not a neutral choice.

What a claim costs beyond the premium increase

The surcharge is only part of the bill:

  • The claims-free discount. Years without a claim earn a discount at most insurers. A claim resets it, and on home insurance IBC and Canadian insurers list a claims-free record as a standard way to lower your rate.
  • Portability. The incident follows you into the market, not just to your current insurer. Accident forgiveness bought at one company does not stop the next company from rating the accident.
  • Record length. Ontario quote applications ask for accidents and claims in the past six years, and traffic violations in the past three.
  • Escalation. Multiple at-fault accidents can mean higher deductibles, reduced coverage options, or a policy that is not renewed, and a record bad enough pushes a driver toward the high-risk market.
  • The deduction you still pay. Unless you were not at fault or only partly at fault, expect to pay your full deductible.

Not-at-fault claims: usually your record, rarely your rate

If the other driver is fully at fault, your rate generally does not increase, though the claim still appears on your history. The mechanism that pays you is Direct Compensation Property Damage (DCPD), which is part of a standard Ontario policy: your own insurer handles your vehicle damage in an Ontario collision that was not your fault.

Two details are worth knowing before you decide to pay your own repair. First, DCPD has been optional to claim since January 2024, when Ontario let drivers elect in writing not to recover it. Opting out can leave a not-at-fault collision running through your collision coverage instead, which means a deductible you would not otherwise have paid. Second, when you are found not at fault or only partly at fault, you generally do not pay the full deductible.

If the other driver is at fault, claiming through DCPD is usually the simplest money you will ever collect, and paying the repair yourself to protect a premium nobody was going to raise is wasted money.

Does accident forgiveness change the answer?

Accident forgiveness, sold as the OPCF 39 endorsement, tells your insurer to ignore your first at-fault accident when pricing your renewal. If you already carry it, claiming is usually the better call, because the premium consequence you were worried about has been bought and paid for.

The limits are strict. It has to be on the policy before the collision, since you cannot add it after the fact. It covers one at-fault accident. It does not transfer to a new insurer, which will rate the accident as though it was never forgiven. It also does not apply to serious conduct such as a Criminal Code conviction, and insurers typically require several years without an at-fault accident before they will sell it to you.

Five questions before you decide

  1. Who will be found at fault? Apply the Fault Determination Rules honestly. A collision where you rear-ended someone is not a 50/50 conversation.
  2. What will the insurer actually pay? That is the repair or replacement cost minus your deductible, and only up to your limits.
  3. Does the damage qualify as minor? If nobody was hurt, no insurer has paid, the damage is under $2,000 per vehicle or property, and you can pay it, Ontario's rule may keep the increase off your record.
  4. What is the premium really worth to you? Multiply the likely increase by the years it will be rated, and add the claims-free discount you lose.
  5. Do you already own forgiveness? If yes, the calculation changes completely. If no, ask what it would cost to add at the next renewal, because the answer is usually smaller than one claim's increase.

When paying out of pocket is usually the right call

  • The repair is close to or below your deductible.
  • You are at fault, nobody was hurt, the other side's damage is modest, and you can pay it, which is the situation Ontario's minor accident rule was written for.
  • The loss is cosmetic: a scratched bumper, a cracked trim piece, a chipped pane you can live with.
  • It is a small home loss, such as a minor interior leak or a broken window, where the surcharge and the lost claims-free discount will outlast the payout.
  • You have a long clean record, no forgiveness endorsement, and a claim would reset a discount you spent years earning.

When you should claim regardless

  • Anyone was injured, including a passenger or the other driver. Injury exposures dwarf premiums and arrive later.
  • You damaged someone else's vehicle or property. Liability is theirs to handle, not yours to settle privately without advice.
  • Your vehicle is undrivable or a total loss.
  • The other driver left the scene or is uninsured. Report it to police, then claim.
  • The loss is large: fire, theft, a burst pipe, wind or water damage.
  • You are not at fault, so DCPD or collision coverage should pay without a full deductible.
  • Someone is claiming against you. Notify your insurer immediately; the duty to defend you sits with them, and late notice is a gift to the other side.

Home insurance: same trade, different numbers

Home policies reward a claims-free record and price a loss into your renewal. Canadian insurers say it plainly: keep a claims-free history to keep the savings, and cover small damage costs yourself. Some sell claims-free protection that behaves like accident forgiveness for the house.

The trap is a small claim. A $1,200 water-damage claim against a home policy can cost a claims-free discount worth more than that over the same years, and some insurers treat repeated small claims more harshly than a single large one. Meanwhile the things you actually need insurance for, a fire, a sewer backup, a major wind loss, are far beyond what most households can absorb. Insure the catastrophe, budget for the nuisance.

After a claim, protect the next renewal

  • Check the fault assessment. Ask your adjuster which Fault Determination rule was applied. If it looks wrong, use the insurer's complaint process, and FSRA if it is still unresolved.
  • Ask about accident forgiveness for the next term, while you still have a record that qualifies.
  • Shop intelligently. An at-fault accident is on your record wherever you go, so expect it to be rated, but insurers weight it differently and some are far gentler on a single incident.
  • Do not absorb the increase by cutting liability limits. That trades a predictable cost for an unpredictable one.
  • Fix the cause. Winter tires, a monitored alarm, a water shut-off device, or a telematics program can offset part of the increase legitimately.

The bottom line

A claim is a trade: you hand your insurer a loss, they hand you money, and then they price the next few years around it. Paying out of pocket is the same trade in reverse. It only makes sense when the number on your side of the ledger is small, nobody was hurt, and no one else's property is in the conversation. When any of those conditions fails, claim without hesitation, and let the policy do the job you bought it for.

Keep reading

Sources

Where Truly Insurance insures across Ontario

Truly Insurance is an Ontario insurance brokerage, and our team of licensed insurance brokers is authorized to arrange coverage anywhere in the province. Our home office is in Kitchener, at 22 Water St S Ste 100, and our brokers work with clients across the Waterloo Region cities of Waterloo, Cambridge, and Guelph, the Southwestern Ontario corridor including London, Brantford, and Stratford, the entire Greater Toronto Area from Toronto and Mississauga to Brampton and Markham, Eastern Ontario including Ottawa and Kingston, and Northern Ontario including Greater Sudbury and Thunder Bay.

You do not have to live near our Kitchener office to work with us. Every Ontario policy is arranged by a named broker who works with you by phone, email, and video, and our team can quote, bind, and service coverage for any address in the province. Find your city or call (519) 800-4770 and a licensed Ontario broker will reach out the same day.

Frequently asked questions

Does one claim raise my car insurance in Ontario?+

It depends on fault. If you are found 50 percent or more at fault there is a good chance your premium rises at renewal, and the accident goes on your insurance record. If you are not at fault your rate generally does not increase, though the claim still appears on your history. One qualifying minor at-fault accident is protected: no injuries, no payment by any insurer, damage under $2,000 per vehicle or property paid by the at-fault driver, once every three years.

How much does an at-fault accident increase insurance in Ontario?+

There is no fixed amount. Intact, for example, describes at-fault collisions as adding anywhere from 20 to 50 percent or more, depending on your prior record and the insurer's own rating rules, and the change arrives at renewal. Insurers also draw their chargeable line differently: Intact treats 26 percent or more at fault as chargeable, while FSRA describes 50 percent or more as the point where a premium increase becomes likely.

Is it cheaper to pay out of pocket or make a claim?+

Compare what the insurer would pay after your deductible with what the claim costs you: the deductible itself, the claims-free discount you lose, and the higher premium for the years the incident stays on your record, which in Ontario means accidents and claims from the past six years are asked about. If the repair is close to your deductible, or small enough to qualify under Ontario's minor at-fault accident rule, paying it yourself is usually cheaper.

Will my premium go up if I report an accident but do not claim?+

Reporting an accident and filing a claim are different steps. Reporting tells your insurer what happened, which FSRA asks you to do within seven days, and it preserves your position if someone reports an injury later. A claim is the request for payment, and it is the claim that drives the rating consequence. Ontario's protection for a minor at-fault accident also requires that no insurer paid anything.

Does a not-at-fault claim raise my premium in Ontario?+

Generally no. Your rate typically does not increase when the other driver is fully at fault, but the claim still appears on your insurance record. The damage is usually handled through Direct Compensation Property Damage, which is part of a standard Ontario policy and has been optional to claim since January 2024, so check that you have not elected it out before assuming a not-at-fault repair will be paid without a deductible.

Does accident forgiveness apply to my claim?+

Only if the OPCF 39 endorsement was already on your policy before the collision, and only for your first at-fault accident. It stops your current insurer from raising your premium because of that accident, but it does not remove the accident from your record and it does not transfer if you switch insurers, who will rate the accident as if it had never been forgiven.

Do I have to report a collision to police in Ontario?+

Ontario's Highway Traffic Act requires a collision to be reported to police when someone is injured, when combined damage exceeds $5,000, or when private, municipal or highway property is damaged. The reportable threshold rose from $2,000 to $5,000 on January 1, 2025. That is separate from the $2,000 per vehicle figure in the insurance rule for minor at-fault accidents, and paying a repair yourself does not remove the duty to report.

Does filing a home insurance claim raise my premium?+

It can, and the cost is usually the claims-free discount plus a surcharge at renewal rather than the payout itself. Canadian insurers recommend covering small damage costs yourself to keep a claims-free record, and some sell claims-free protection for exactly that reason. Reserve the policy for losses you could not absorb, such as fire, a major water loss, or a large wind claim.

What happens if I do not tell my insurer about an accident?+

Silence carries risk. FSRA warns that failing to report within a reasonable time may mean the insurer does not honour the claim, Intact notes that an accident not reported to police can be treated as an at-fault claim under collision coverage, and a knowingly false statement on an application or renewal can invalidate a claim under Ontario's Insurance Act. Report the incident, then decide with your broker whether to claim.

Get a quote, fast.

Compare top Canadian insurers with a licensed Ontario broker.

Start your quote

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not financial or insurance advice. Rates, coverage, and eligibility vary by individual circumstances, insurer, and region. Always contact a licensed insurance broker for guidance specific to your situation.

Talk to a broker who explains everything.

Personal quotes, fast. Commercial coverage typically in a few days.